Comparison · MacroFactor
Cookrange vs. MacroFactor
Last verified:
MacroFactor reverse-calculates your real metabolic rate from logged intake and weight trend and updates your target automatically; it was built by Stronger By Science's founders and has no free tier. Cookrange takes the other route: the target is a calorie range worked out from your profile, it changes when your weight, goal or activity level there changes, and it does not follow your weight trend; calories burned are shown on their own line.
MacroFactor reverse-calculates your real metabolic rate (TDEE) from the relationship between your logged calorie intake and your weight trend, then updates that estimate automatically as you keep logging consistently. It was built by Stronger By Science founders Greg Nuckols and Eric Trexler, is reported to score around 8–8.4/10 across several review sites, and is well-regarded among evidence-minded fitness enthusiasts. Cookrange takes the other route, and the two apps differ plainly on when the target itself changes: MacroFactor adjusts it automatically based on your weight trend, while Cookrange works it out from an age/weight/activity formula as a calorie range and changes it when your weight, goal or activity level in your profile changes. Calories burned from a workout you log are shown on their own line and do not move it.
Comparison table
| Area | MacroFactor | Cookrange |
|---|---|---|
| How the target is set | Reverse-calculates TDEE from logged intake and weight trend, rather than an age/weight/activity formula | A calorie range and a protein minimum worked out from your profile and goal with an age/weight/activity formula (Mifflin-St Jeor) |
| How the target updates afterward | Updates automatically and continuously as your weight trend changes — no manual action needed | It changes when your weight, goal or activity level in your profile changes; it does not follow your weight trend on its own. Calories burned from a workout you log are shown on their own line and do not change it. Swapping a meal, or logging something you ate instead, recalculates the day’s meals; that is a separate mechanism and leaves the daily target alone |
| Meal plan / recipe suggestions | Gives you a macro target and lets you log your own recipes; its own App Store description describes tracking and target-setting, not meal suggestions or plan generation (checked 2026-08-28) | An actual weekly meal plan built from a recipe library around your goals, recipes included; calories and protein are computed from the ingredients |
| Free tier | None — only a 7-day free trial (some sources report promo codes extending it to 14 days); afterward $11.99/mo or $71.99/yr (checked 2026-08-28) | Core features (logging, plans, recipes, community, streaks) always free; recipe generation and chat share a 2-a-day AI allowance on the free tier, and planning the week uses none of it; premium raises your AI generation limit and unlocks the 30-day nutrition trend, the BMR/TDEE breakdown and group CSV export |
| Gym/social integration | No documented gym check-in or social accountability feature found as of 2026-08-05 — sources change | QR check-in, a weekly leaderboard, squads; each member keeps their own streak; built, not yet exercised end to end with a real gym |
Which one fits
For people who log their weight consistently, want their target to adjust on its own, and would rather log freely against a number than expect a meal plan or recipe suggestions, MacroFactor’s automatic TDEE model is a strong option. For people who want to see what to eat as an actual plan, stay motivated alongside gym friends, and use the core features without paying anything, Cookrange takes a different approach.
For a broader list of evaluation criteria, see what to look for in a nutrition tracking app.