Nutrition
Why a Daily Calorie Range Instead of One Number
A daily calorie target is an estimate before you eat a single thing, so Cookrange shows it as a range rather than one number. A day centred on 2,000 kcal has a range of 1,900 to 2,100 kcal, and the day is read against that band: finishing at 1,950 kcal isn’t “50 short”, it’s in range.
That can look like a presentation detail. It isn’t. A number should be no more precise than the sums behind it, and a target built from an unmeasured metabolism, average food values and portions judged by eye has no business claiming “2,000, not one calorie either way”. The range stops pretending.
How is the range worked out?
Start with the centre. Cookrange works it out from your profile: your height, weight, age and sex go into the Mifflin-St Jeor equation for your basal metabolic rate, an activity multiplier between 1.2 and 1.725 turns that into maintenance calories, and your goal adds an adjustment. If you want to lose weight, the deficit never exceeds a quarter of maintenance, and the centre never drops below your basal metabolic rate or below 1,200 kcal for women and 1,500 kcal for men. If you’re under 18, if your goal weight would put your BMI under 18.5, or if you’re already under that line and asking to lose, no deficit is applied at all.
It is the same arithmetic the site’s calorie calculator runs, and the calculator is checked against the app’s own test cases on every update. The range is that centre, plus or minus 5%.
Protein gets a range too, set in grams per kilogram for your goal (1.6 to 2.2 g/kg when losing weight, for example; the protein calculator has the rest). When the day is judged, though, protein works as a floor: once you reach the bottom of that range, you’ve had enough.
A personal range needs two things from you: your allergies declared (“none” counts as an answer) and explicit consent to process your health data. Without consent, no personal number is worked out.
Isn’t the range just a margin of error?
No, and it’s worth being plain about that. The centre carries more uncertainty than 5%. A 2005 systematic review by Frankenfield and colleagues found Mifflin-St Jeor the most reliable of the four common equations, landing within 10% of measured resting metabolism for more people than any other, while noting that sizeable errors remain when it’s applied to individuals. Your centre could be off by a few hundred calories.
The 5% band doesn’t try to fix that. Its job is humbler: a sensible tolerance for reading one day of eating. Portions are guessed, one tomato isn’t the next, some of the oil stays in the pan. None of that is a reason to tell anyone they missed.
So why not wider? Because a 20% band would put nearly every day in range and tell you nothing. If the centre is wrong for you, the fix isn’t a wider band; it’s a few weeks of weight trend and an updated profile. The target is worked out again whenever the weight, goal or activity level in your profile changes.
What does “in range” actually mean?
On the home screen, the day’s range is written on the plate and what you’ve eaten moves round its rim as an arc. Everything you logged today counts: planned meals, and anything you added by photo, barcode or quick add. While the day is under way, one sentence under the plate looks at the rest of the plan, along the lines of “Dinner brings you into your range.” or “You’re in your range, and the rest of the plan keeps you there.”
The week view draws each day as a bar against its own range, with a tally at the top such as “3 / 4 days in range”. Only finished days count, and a finished day is in range when the calories you ate that day landed inside its band. Protein isn’t part of that tally; the plan’s day view shows it separately, against its minimum.
What happens when a day ends outside the range?
Very little, by design. The sentence under the plate gives the gap in calories: “You’re 180 kcal over your range. One day doesn’t undo a week.” In the week view that day’s bar sits outside its band and the day isn’t counted among those in range. That’s all.
What doesn’t happen matters more. Tomorrow’s plan isn’t trimmed to claw the difference back, the target doesn’t move, and the next meal isn’t shrunk as a penalty. If you eat something off the plan during the day, the day’s remaining meals are re-portioned within limits, which has its own post. But when the day is over, it’s over.
The signal worth acting on isn’t one day; it’s a pattern. Weeks of days ending on the same side of the band say either that the centre doesn’t fit you or that the shape of the plan doesn’t fit your days. For the first, keep your profile current. For the second, change the number of snacks or your office days. If neither explains it, that’s the point to talk to a dietitian.
One number versus a range
| A single target | A daily range | |
|---|---|---|
| How the target reads | 2,000 kcal | 1,900 to 2,100 kcal |
| A day ending at 1,950 kcal | 50 kcal short | In range |
| A day ending at 2,150 kcal | 150 kcal over | 50 kcal over the range |
| Small deviations | Every one counts as a miss | Up to 5% reads as normal |
| Uncertainty in the centre itself | Hidden by the number’s precision | Not fixed by the band; fixed by updating your profile |
What the range doesn’t tell you
The range isn’t a prescription or a medical target. It’s an equation built from population data, applied to your profile. If you’re pregnant, breastfeeding, have a history of disordered eating, or live with a condition that affects how you should eat, work with a doctor or a dietitian rather than an app’s number.
Days that end in range don’t guarantee weight loss or better health. They only show where you stand against the plan’s own arithmetic.
Frequently asked questions
Is finishing in the middle of the range better than finishing at the edge? Not for how the day is judged: a day that ends anywhere inside the band is in range. When the plan builds a day, though, it aims close to the centre and sizes the portions for it.
Does the range grow on days I train? On the days you choose as training days, yes: each counts as about an hour of moderate training, so its range is higher and the plan adds an after-training meal. A workout you log is different: its calories appear on their own line and don’t change the day’s target.
If I stay in range every day, am I guaranteed to lose weight? No. The centre is an estimate and may be off for you, and the range doesn’t correct that. If your weight trend over a few weeks disagrees with your goal, update your profile, and if you have a health condition, speak to a doctor or a dietitian.
Where to go from here
To see your own centre, try the calorie calculator; the app’s range is 5% either side of that number. How the plan fills the range is on the nutrition planning page. Cookrange is currently at v0.9.6 internal alpha and isn’t in the app stores yet; if you’d like early access, join the waitlist.
This post is part of a short “why it’s different” series. The others: how a recipe’s calories are computed from its ingredients, how the plan follows your kitchen and what happens after an off-plan meal.